Briefs · creative
Creative Writing Critique
Get honest, craft-level feedback on a piece of writing.
You walk away with
A craft critique with what works, what does not, and how to fix it.
Decidi convenes
📖 The Storyteller✒️ The Editor-in-Chief🥃 Ernest Hemingway🎬 The Creative Director✍️ The Copywriter💬 The Brutally Honest Friend
Recommended level: Standard — Proven pro models — the everyday default.
What the council debates
Critique this piece of creative writing at a craft level. Be honest — I want to make it better, not feel good. THE PIECE: [paste the writing — story, chapter, poem, script excerpt] WHAT IT IS: [genre, form, intended audience, where it sits in a larger work] WHAT I AM UNSURE ABOUT: [my own doubts] Debate: 1. Does it work — does it land emotionally and hold attention. 2. Voice and style — distinctive and consistent, or generic. 3. Structure and pacing — where it drags, where it rushes. 4. Character and stakes — do I care, and why or why not. 5. The prose at the line level — clarity, rhythm, the lines that sing and the ones that clunk. 6. The single change that would most raise the quality. FINAL SYNTHESIS: - What is genuinely working and must be kept. - A prioritised list of issues with concrete suggestions (and a rewritten line or two as example). - The one revision that matters most.